Color: Does It Affect Behavior?
Niki Jankowiak
St. Bonaventure University
As sun began to
peer over the horizon, the sky revealed hues of reds, oranges and yellows,
which signified the arrival of a new day.
As the daylight faded and was replaced by a hovering blanket of
darkness, daily activities were replaced by hours filled with sleep. The
earliest humans were able to recognize that sunlight was essential to life.
“Color, being a manifestation of light, held divine meaning. Historical records
of color show little interest in the physical nature of color, nor yet in its
abstract beauty, but in a symbolism that attempted to resolve the strange
workings of creation and give it personal and human meaning” (Birren 1961).
The Ancient Egyptians and Greeks gave color a significant role in healing techniques which they attributed to the god Thoth or Hermes Trismegistus, which would later be called the Hermetic tradition. The Ancient Egyptians and Greeks along with the Chinese and Indians used colored minerals, stones, crystals, salves, and dyes as remedies, and painted treatment sanctuaries in various shades of color” (Graham 1998). Based on Aristotle’s four elements: air, fire, water, and earth, the Greeks believed that the body was made up of four humors, each of which was associated with a color: choler (yellow bile), blood (red), phlegm (white), and melancholy (black bile). Choler or yellow bile meant one was inclined to anger. Blood was the humor associated with optimism, confidence, and happiness. Phlegm (white) meant passivity or coolness. Melancholy or black bile meant depressed or saddened. These four humors were thought to determine the emotional and physical condition of the person; if an imbalance occurred, disease resulted. In order to restore the proper balance, colored garments, oils, plasters, and ointments were used to treat disease and restore balance. These ideas carried up to the Middle Ages until the rise of Christianity when the Church banned the healing practices of the Ancient Greeks, Egyptians, and Romans. “The ancient healing arts, preserved by secret oral tradition passed on to the initiates, thus became hidden or occult” (Graham 1998).
People
continued to pass on the ancient traditions and therefore to assume that color
played a vital role in health and behavior.
The church persecuted many as pagans or witches, but some gained notable
fame and success. Much work done in the
field of color was dismissed as unscientific, such as studies of Augustus
Pleasanton in the 1870s. One claim made
by Pleasanton that was dismissed said that blue light was effective in treating
disease and pain. But in 1990,
scientists with the American Association for the Advancement of science
reported on the successful use of blue light in the treatment of addictions,
eating disorders, jaundice, impotence, and depression.
Also
skeptically looked upon were the unempirical work of Max Luscher, a professor
of psychology. He developed a
psychological theory, which he did not back with empirical evidence, that color
for man originated in early history. He
believed that the two basic environments of darkness (dark blues) and daylight
(yellows) accounted for the differences in metabolic rate glandular secretions
appropriate to the energy levels required for nighttime sleep or daytime
activity. He developed a color test upon which he believed personality could be
determined, but conventional psychology dismisses the possibility of breaking
down the complete complex personality of a human based on color, though the
color test may be useful in conjunction with various other testing
methods. Modern research now believes
that exposure to light and darkness is linked to hormonal secretions of
melatonin and serotonin. Melatonin is
linked to sleep, and is found in high levels in people suffering from eating
disorders and seasonal depression during the winter months; whereas serotonin
is a stimulant that is produced during the day and increases with exposure to
natural sunlight or artificial full spectrum lamps.
Before continuing, let’s first examine
how the human eye experiences color. In
the physical world, there are no colors, only wavelengths. The human eye has the ability to distinguish
hundreds of wavelengths. The eye is
able to see when light stimulates the retina. The retina consists of rods and
cones. The rods, located in the peripheral retina, allow us night vision but
cannot distinguish color. The cones, located in the center of the retina, allow
us to perceive color during daylight conditions but operate poorly in dark
conditions. For this reason, when
walking outside at night, object may appear in shades of gray or black instead
of their normal coloration. The cones
each contain a light sensitive pigment, which is sensitive over a range of
wavelengths. Each visible color is a different wavelength within the color
spectrum. Genes contain the coding instructions for these pigments, and if the
coding instructions are incorrect, the wrong pigments are produced, resulting
in a color deficiency or more commonly called color blindness (Kosslyn,
Rosenberg 2003). The color the human
eye is able to experience is minute in comparison to the vastness of wavelengths
that exist. Observe the diagram below:
Dr.
Bill Blair (http://violet.pha.jhu.edu/~wpb/spectroscopy/spec_home.html)
Though there is a biological base for our color vision, everyone experiences wavelengths differently. Color deficiencies, personal experiences and cultural factors may contribute to how we react to these colors. Is how we react to colors in part also genetically encoded? Traditional studies tend to lend themselves to the concept that colors in one’s environment plays a more significant role than genetics. One factor that also must be considered is that people can develop links of given stimuli to specific behaviors and that these linkages will very quickly override many of the secondary or more subtle innate responses. In simpler terms, a learned response to a color will prevail over any other response normally expected to take place. An example of this can be seen in an article from the website Color Matters- The Body:
A
mother watches a bright red car zoom by. A second later her child is on the
ground, critically hurt, hit by the car. The child survives, but the trauma is
so instant, so deep, the woman's association of bright red to horrible loss is
forever buried in her psyche. A linkage has been formed. Ever since then, when
she sees that bright red, her heart races and an intense fear moves through
her. She rejects that color and keeps it away... Does bright red equal horrid
loss then? To her it does. It's a uniquely formed, special case linkage. But to
you, or me that same bright red might mean something good, a warm Valentine's
moment, a spouse's beautiful lips, whatever. The situational induced linkage of
that bright red to that traumatic fearful moment overrides whatever response to
the color might otherwise prevail.
In environmental study with color and
light, conducted by visual-arts professor Harry Wohlfarth and Catharine Sam of
the University of Alberta, the color environment of fourteen severely
handicapped and behaviorally disordered eight to eleven years old was altered.
It involved substituting yellow and blue for orange, white, beige and brown and
replacing fluorescent lights with full-spectrum ones. After a change in color
and lighting environment, the children's aggressive behavior diminished and
then blood pressure dropped. Interestingly, the same effects were found in both
blind and sighted children in Wohlfarth and Sam's study. This suggests that color
energies affect in ways that transcend seeing. One hypothesis is that
neurotransmitters in the eye transmit information about light to the brain even
in the absence of sight, and that this information releases a hormone in the
hypothalamus that has numerous effects on our moods, mental clarity, and energy
level. In what Wohlfarth calls the science of Colorpsychodynamics, colors that
seem to increase blood pressure, pulse, and respiration rate are, in order of
increasing effects, warm colors such as red, orange and yellow (Sasaki
2002). This idea is reminiscent to
Luscher’s theory involving glandular secretions.
Graham, 1998, relates and interesting
story to the reader in which she conversed with the governer of a newly built
prison in which each of the four wings had been painted a different color: red,
yellow, blue and green. Prisoners were
randomly places in each of the four wings.
Violent behavior among inmates occurred most commonly in the red, and
yellow wings in comparison to the blue and green wings. Experimental research has found that viewing
red light increases a subject’s strength by 13.5 percent and a 5.8 percent
increase in electrical activity of the arm muscle.
Pink has been found to have a
tranquilizing and calming effect within minutes of exposure in prisons. It
suppresses hostile, aggressive, and anxious behavior. Dr. Alexander
Schauss, Ph.D., director of the American Institute for Biosocial Research in
Tacoma Washington, was the first to report the suppression of angry,
antagonistic, and anxiety ridden behavior among prisoners: “Even if a person
tries to be angry or aggressive in the presence of pink [specifically
Baker-Miller Pink], he can't. The heart muscles can’t race fast enough. It’s a
tranquilizing color that saps your energy. Even the color-blind are
tranquilized by pink rooms.” In spite of
these powerful effects, there is substantial evidence that these reactions are
short term. Once the body returns to a state of equilibrium, a prisoner may
regress to an even more agitated state (Color
Matters-The Body 2002). Pink holding
cells are now widely used to reduce violent and aggressive behavior among
prisoners, sources reporting a reduction of muscle strength in inmates within
2.7 seconds (Graham 1985).
“One would indeed
be an iconoclast to reject color entirely. Its role in all forms of life is too
evident to be either denied or ignored” (Birren 1961). Upon investigating this topic, I believe
that color does play a significant role in our lives. I also recognize that
personal experiences and culture will help to define color in certain and
crucial ways, such as in the example of the mother and the red car. I take specific interest in the use of light
in reducing depression and treating other disorders, seeing as it has a direct
effect on the brain and nervous system resulting in the release of hormones and
thus affecting behavior. Researchers in
the field admit that the uses of color and the effects they have on behavior is
just currently beginning to win over the attention and investigation it
deserves. Hopefully in the future, the
mystery of color will be unraveled to the benefit of people everywhere.
Works Cited
Birren, Faber. Color Psychology and Color Therapy: A Factual Study of the
Influence of Color on Human Life. University Books, 1961.
Graham,
Heather. Color Therapy-Then &
Now. Article Index.com. September 17, 2002 <http://www.ask.com/main/metaAnswer.asp?t=ai&s=a&MetaEngine=directhit&en=te&eo=2&o=0&frames=True&url=http%3A%2F%2Fask%2Edirecthit%2Ecom%2Ffcgi%2Dbin%2Fredirurl%2Efcg%3Furl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fwww%2Earticleindex%2Ecom%2FHealth%2FColor%5FTherapy%5Fpart%5F1%2Ehtm%26qry%3Dhumors%2Band%2Bcolor%2Bof%2Bthe%2Bblood%26rnk%3D1%26cz%3D99aa33095efe5de1%26src%3DDH%5FASK%5FSRCH%26uid%3D0fc518a3428f9b9b3%26sid%3D1c767333dc77cf8d3%26u%3D&ac=7&adcat=hlth&pt=Color+Therapy+Part+1&dm=http%3A%2F%2Fwww%2Earticleindex%2Ecom%2FHealth%2FColor%5FTherapy%5Fpart%5F1%2Ehtm&io=0&qid=B05A7E50D91F3640AF7FCAB9C2B5E0A3&back=ask%3Dhumors%2Band%2Bcolor%2Bof%2Bthe%2Bblood%26o%3D0%26qsrc%3D0%26meta%3D1%26IMAGE1%2Ex%3D12%26IMAGE1%2Ey%3D5&ask=humors+and+color+of+the+blood&dt=020923190259&amt=>.
Kosslyn, Stephen M., Robin S. Rosenberg. Fundamentals of Psychology: The Brian, The Person, The World. Boston: Pearson Education, Inc., 2003.
Morton, J. L. Drunk Tank Pink. Color Maters-The Body. September 18, 2002 <http://www.ask.com/main/metaAnswer.asp?t=ai&s=a&MetaEngine=directhit&en=te&eo=3&o=0&frames=True&url=http%3A%2F%2Fask%2Edirecthit%2Ecom%2Ffcgi%2Dbin%2Fredirurl%2Efcg%3Furl%3Dhttp%3A%2F%2Fwww%2Ecolormatters%2Ecom%2Fbody%5Fpink%2Ehtml%26qry%3Ddoes%2Bthe%2Bcolor%2Bpink%2Bcalm%2Bprisoners%26rnk%3D1%26cz%3D76c8d8fda8bb7acf%26src%3DDH%5FASK%5FSRCH%26uid%3D0fc518a3428f9b9b3%26sid%3D1e462f9cf1c6b09d3%26u%3D&ac=11&adcat=home&pt=Color+Matters+%2D+The+Body+%2D+Drunk+Tank+Pink&dm=http%3A%2F%2Fwww%2Ecolormatters%2Ecom%2Fbody%5Fpink%2Ehtml&io=0&qid=9EA9255350C90446B4C07EE91CACC3C1&back=ask%3Ddoes%2Bthe%2Bcolor%2Bpink%2Bcalm%2Bprisoners%26o%3D0%26qsrc%3D0%26meta%3D1%26IMAGE1%2Ex%3D17%26IMAGE1%2Ey%3D13&ask=does+the+color+pink+calm+prisoners&dt=020924120405&amt=>.
Sasaki,
Hiroshi. Color psychology. September 15, 2002.
<http://www.shibuya.com/garden/colorpsycho.html>.
Color Psychology.
Wu, Shelly, Ph.D. The Psychology of Color. September 17, 2002 <http://psychology.about.com/library/weekly/aa031501a.htm>.