II. “The Consideration of
God in His Footsteps in This Visible World” by Bonaventure
Where does this step fit
within Bonaventure's idea of the ascent? Why?
Does his idea (§3) of sense
perception as the "portal" to the world still hold?
In §4 Bonaventure provides
an abbreviated account of the medieval theory of sense perception. Its essence
is that things enter the human senses through "similitudes" generated
in the medium. Can you follow the general sense of this theory? Does it make sense from the point of view of
contemporary theories about sensation?
What is the cause of the
delight (aesthetic pleasure) for the senses during the transmission of the
"similitude" (§5, also see §6)? Do you agree with Bonaventure's
opinion that this principle is the essence of beauty?
What is the
"judgment" that Bonaventure is speaking about in §6? Is it rational
(logical) judgment? What sort of status do senses acquire, according to
Bonaventure, through their ability to make this sort of judgment? How do the
senses "prepare" sense impressions for the intellect?
In what sense are the things
of the external world images, pictures, and echoes of God (§11-13)? How do they
lead to God? How does this understanding of the nature of sensible things fit
into Bonaventure's scheme of ascent?
Can you explain how these
reflections of Bonaventure might provide a framework for reading some of the
creative responses to nature found in poetry or art?